First, philosophical exercise is no longer, clearly, a tearing away from. The quotes of plato have generally been drawn from plato, complete works, ed. Hadots recurring theme is that philosophy in antiquity was characterized by a series of spiritual exercises intended to transform the perception, and therefore the being, of those who practice it. Hadots move necessitates a new definition of spiritual exercise, in two senses. This is not a book for the casual reader butit is an important publication and.
Genre is another significant theme explored in buddhist spiritual practices. Spiritual exercises from socrates to foucault pdf epub book. Studies the place of cosmic consciousness and spiritual exercises within pierre hadots notion of philosophy as a way of life. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Introduction to philosophy of pierre hadot or on to. The ways in the ways in which the account of nussbaum can be defended are then discussed, including. Hadots work have been published so far, aside from davidsons articles and prefaces. Studies the place of cosmic consciousness and spiritual exercises within pierre hadot s notion of philosophy as a way of life. Hadots treatment of marcus aurelius ta eis eauton or meditations in his long essay in pwl, and in the book the inner citadel, serves well to bring together both the methodological concerns governing hadots readings of classical thought and this conception of ancient philosophy as revolving around a series of spiritual exercises.
Pierre hadot s interpretation of ancient greek and roman philosophy in terms of philosophy as a way of life constituted by spiritual exercises has received considerable attention from scholars of the period as well as by persons who welcome his defense of a way of doing philosophy that is more practical than dominant academic approaches today. Apr 12, 2020 hadot pierre ejercicios espirituales y filosofia antigua 1 maria jose marked it as toread mar 28, aug 28, sean a. The first edition of the novel was published in 1981, and was written by pierre hadot. Pdf therapeutic arguments, spiritual exercises, or the. Davidson, translated by michael chase, oxfordcambridge, mass basil blackwell, 1995.
This essay is a reappraisal of pierre hadots concept of spiritual exercises in response to recent criticisms of his work. The author argues that contrary to the claims of his critics, hadot articulates a compelling argument that spiritual exercises that employ imaginative, rhetorical, and cognitive techniques are both necessary for and successful at producing a subject in which. Hadot credits the rise of christianity with the decline of philosophy practiced as a way of life. In his book philosophy as a way of life pierre hadot writes on what he calls spiritual exercises which lead to a transformation or metamorphosis of our life. Hadots essays exhibit impressive scholarship and a habit ofprofound reflection. English part iv themes 215 philosophy as a way of life. Pierre hadot, arnold davidson this book presents a history of spiritual exercises from socrates to early christianity, an account of their decline in modern philosophy, and a discussion of the different conceptions of philosophy that have accompanied the trajectory and fate of the theory and practice of spiritual exercises. A magisterial mappa mundi of the terrain that pierre hadot has so productively worked for decades, this ambitious work revises our view of ancient philosophy. You can feel hadots incredible intellectual rigor and equally incredible passion for engaged philosophy. The main characters of this philosophy, non fiction story are.
Like hadot, foucault became invested in ancient philosophy, specifically for its conception of ethics as the care of the self. Remembering pierre hadot part i harvard university. Pierre hadot has contributed two exceptional works on philosophical practice, the second of which is an overview of ancient philosophy. The inner citadel pierre hadot harvard university press. Pierre hadot as a reader of wittgenstein paragraph. Christianity positioned itself as a philosophy in hadots sense with its own regimen of spiritual exercises and spiritual goals, and as this religion came to eclipse the various pagan philosophies, it usurped their spiritual function. Aquinas, hadot, and spiritual exercises kruger 2017. Pierre hadot, epicurean spiritual exercises counter. This book presents a history of spiritual exercises from socrates to early christianity, an account of their decline in modern philosophy, and a discussion of the different conceptions of philosophy that have accompanied the trajectory and fate of the theory and practice of spiritual exercises. Therapeutic arguments, spiritual exercises, or the care of the self. Spiritual exercises pierre hadot mikeysmetaphysics.
Martha nussbaum, pierre hadot and michel foucault on ancient philosophy. Pierre hadots interpretation of ancient greek and roman philosophy in terms of philosophy as a way of life constituted by spiritual exercises has received considerable attention from scholars of the period as well as by persons who welcome his defense of a way of doing philosophy that is more practical than dominant academic approaches today. Remembering pierre hadot part i harvard university press blog. Hadot s essays exhibit impressive scholarship and a habit ofprofound reflection. Hadots book demonstrates the extent to which philosophy has been, and still is, above all else a way. Dec 29, 2017 here are 5 of my favorite big ideas from the inner citadel by pierre hadot. Includes discussion of some of his contemporary critics, and the possible relevance of some recent studies on. Mar 12, 2015 in this video we investigate, building on the works of pierre hadot, how the ancient philosophers conceived philosophy as a way of life.
Hadots book demonstrates the extent to which philosophy has been, and still is, above all else. Here are 5 of my favorite big ideas from the inner citadel by pierre hadot. This contains hadots classic article on spiritual exercises. Pdf pierre hadot and his critics on spiritual exercises and. In this article, hadot first outlined his realization that many of the writings of the hellenistic philosophers were really meant to be read as exercises that would help instill in the philosopher the teachings of that particular school. Hadot pierre ejercicios espirituales y filosofia antigua 1 maria jose marked it as toread mar 28, aug 28, sean a. Introduction to philosophy of pierre hadot or on to spiritual. Free download or read online philosophy as a way of life. The concept of spiritual exercises remains a viable component of theoretical frameworks for the study of religious ethics, though the author concludes that hadot s position on habit and its role in ethical practice requires further investigation. The first edition of this novel was published in 1981, and was written by pierre hadot. According to hadot, the performativity of a practice or spiritual exercise is intimately tied to a universal which transcends the individual self, whereas foucault maintains that it does not. Ignatius of loyola translated from the autograph by father elder mullan, s. The main characters of this philosophy, non fiction. To a certain extent, the ethic of dialogue, which is, for plato, the spiritual exercise par excellence, is linked to another fundamental procedure, the sublimation of love.
Smoothome rated it really liked it nov 23, thanks for telling us about the problem. Pierre hadot deserves to be better known to englishlanguage readersand not just because he was a favorite of michel foucaults and is the man largely responsible for introducing wittgenstein to the french. An exercise in thinking with and against hadot, introduces a number of distinctions that parse hadots category of spiritual exercises. The work of pierre hadot can highlight understudied aspects of the work of thomas aquinas. Pierre hadot on habit, reason, and spiritual exercises. Pdf pierre hadot and his critics on spiritual exercises. Pierre hadot,platos spiritual exercises countercurrents.
This contains hadot s classic article on spiritual exercises. Hadot s recurring theme is that philosophy in antiquity was characterized by a series of spiritual exercises intended to transform the perception, and therefore the being, of those who practice it. Hadots active stoic exercises by anitra russell modern. Spiritual exercises from socrates to foucault by hadot, pierre, davidson, arnold isbn. Pierrejulien harters essay, spiritual exercises and the buddhist path. At the center of the study is the strikingly original notion of the spiritual exercise, which professor hadot here and elsewhere shows to lie at the heart of greek hellenistic thinking about man, morality, and the universe. Oct 26, 2016 the work of pierre hadot can highlight understudied aspects of the work of thomas aquinas. Brian stock, university of toronto hadots what is ancient philosophy. According to the myth of the preexistence of souls, the soul has seen, when it had not yet descended into the body, the forms, the transcendental norms. The inner citadel by pierre hadot philosophersnotes. Pierre hadot was one of the most influential historians of ancient philosophy. Hadot s spiritual exercises intrigued michel foucault, whose thought took a similar spiritual turn late in his life, at least after a fashion.
Selfmastery, accomplishment of duties, and indifference to indifferent things hadot describes several types of spiritual exercises, including the more wellknown morning and evening meditationsin which you look ahead at the day to come, or reflect on the day that has passed, and consider how you. Introduction to philosophy of pierre hadot or on to spiritual exercises janis skesteris university of latvia 2830 marstalu str. Pierre hadot a few years ago, i became invested in spirituality as a humanistic subject. Hadot offers two key concepts in his study of ancient philosophy. The spiritual exercises jesuit conference of canada and.
Pierre hadot on habit, reason, and spiritual exercises del. Spiritual exercises from socrates to foucault by pierre hadot book free download 320 pages free download or read online philosophy as a way of life. Pierre hadot and michel foucault on spiritual exercises. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 320 pages and is available in paperback format. Hadot takes ancient philosophy out of its customary realm of names, dates, and arid abstractions and plants it squarely in the thick of life. The inner citadel is a rich and substantial book and will certainly affect future scholarship on marcus aurelius. Feb 27, 2015 in his book philosophy as a way of life pierre hadot writes on what he calls spiritual exercises which lead to a transformation or metamorphosis of our life.
908 1156 944 1132 254 1392 1372 852 1190 27 491 140 1435 711 1012 523 1035 456 440 977 748 1136 151 200 410 1405 38 663 417 597 802 980 755 1048 340 277 55 1134 748 845 1132 154 497 700 538 1059 239 45